Evidence of proof
The upcoming Dalai Lama talk at a major science conference has drawn strong opposition to recent research he’s contributed to on the relationship between meditation and human experience.
For most people who have a daily practice of any kind, whether it’s meditation, yoga, music, cooking, art, or whatever else, it’s a craft more than a science. We don’t seek proof outside our experience. Affirmation or deinial from an auditorium full of fiesty pointy-penciled scientists has little meaning for us.
We do it because of what it does to and for us. And as we say in any craft: If I miss a day, I notice; if I miss two days, you notice.
October 22nd, 2005 21:11
I really enjoy your site, Jack.
I find the first sentence of this blog entry grammatically confusing. Is the opposition to the upcoming conference or the previous research? The way it reads it sounds like the upcoming talk is opposing the previous research. Anyway, just trying to understand.
As one who benefits from a daily meditation practice, I can agree that my experience doesn’t require scientific validation. However, in this western world it’s a fact that many of those unfamiliar with meditative benefits may only try it for themselves when “science” shows them concrete experimental benefits, and may otherwise dismiss it as a waste of time. I know people like this. Science may be the advertising package they need to “get in the door”. The practice will speak for itself.
In my humble opinion, the Dalai Lama has been very generous in trying to accommodate and reach the western mind in this way.
Thanks again for the site.
Dawn
fellow Ohio City sitter
October 22nd, 2005 21:25
Thanks Dawn, and yes the opposition is to the research because many scientists don’t think it’s been validly approached yet.
I agree that advertising can lure people in the door, but that will not keep people on their cushion day after day. Only direct benefits will inspire the long term.
October 23rd, 2005 17:58
There are is a plethora of peer-reviewed published papers on the phenomena. Dawn, youe should recognize the work of JH’ers John Deluca and Tony King. Here is a link to John’s work:
http://www.fearlessheart.com/downloads.htm